Another "make me want to VOMIT" adoption column.....Where do these folks get their material? The latest was a piece of work! How his editors let this go thru I'll never know. And just for the record long ago in a previous life (my 20's :)) I was an editor.. not for a newspaper but we used reverent quips, comments, twists in lots we did and I NEVER in a million years would have allowed this to go thru.... Anyway, here's link but will attach copy too...http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/opinion/columnists/seate/s_573477.htmlTitle of column is :Adopting Asian Kids Becoming latest Fad! (grhhhhhh)And you know I'd be ticked whether our children were Asian, African American, purple polka dotted people eaters.. It's just sooooo lame and ignorant. I mean I dont expect every person on the planet to be PC but give me a break..I have a confession .. one of my fav sitcoms which we no longer get cause we cancelled HBO shortly after the kids came home is : Sex and the City (maybe Sex in the City).. I "LOVE" it because it's funny, witty, and mostly deals with the in-depth friendships of 4 women living in New York City. I mention it cause it's mentioned in his article (as being 4 "screwed up women")...AND during this difficult year, with Andrew's hard transition, where I was perhaps in front of my computer more than I should have been..... I downloaded some seasons I 'd missed, to watch here and there. I must say that I wanted to ALSO vomit as one of the characters was having a hard time conceiving and her gay friend says: " well if this doesnt work out (domestic adoption) I know some gay friends who just got a baby from Guatemala for like $100.. ".. I HATE, HATE stuff like this but at least in this instance, the main character's reaction to that statement said much.... made it a bit better. However, unfortunately in real life this crap happens.. happens all the time.Anyway, this is his article and my ltr to him follows.. for your reading pleasure :) And sorry cant seem to fix the break in middle of article......
Adopting Asian kids becoming latest fad
By Mike Seate
TRIBUNE-REVIEW
Thursday, June 19, 2008
Though I may not be ready for sainthood, I am owed some accolades for having sat through not one, but two, chick flicks with my wife in as many weekends. Few experiences are as emasculating and downright testosterone-sapping as viewing films made exclusively for and marketed toward the female gender.
Their plot lines are centered almost entirely around emoting and the dashed expectations of true love. I often find myself enduring their 120-plus minutes by thinking, "Boy, she's going to watch six World Superbike races and a whole season of 'Tank Overhaul' for this one!"
Although I spent most of my sentence, I mean time, during this all-estrogen double feature counting lint balls in my pockets and fishing for popcorn caught between my bicuspids and gums, something in both these otherwise interminable films did manage to pierce my thick fog of indifference.
In "Then She Found Me," Helen Hunt portrays a neurotic mess of a woman who screws up every relationship in her life and can't tell good men from rotten ones. Unable to conceive a child naturally, Hunt's character decides to reward herself with something guaranteed to make her character and the audience smile: a Chinese baby girl. The film ends with long, lingering shots of the kid's smiling face, and half the women around us were fighting back tears. I was, too, but mine were because I'd never recover those lost two hours of my life.
One week later, I suffered through an afternoon screening of the glitzy handbag commercial cleverly disguised as a major motion picture known as "Sex and the City." In that one, Charlotte, one member of the quartet of ditzy, clothes-obsessed main characters, couldn't conceive a child naturally.
The solution? She adopts one of those adorable Chinese babies you've heard so much about -- forcing viewers to spend much of the next 90 minutes of film watching these four screwed-up women as they screw up some kid who would be better off in a rice paddy 7,000 miles from any of them.
Call me cynical, but since when did Asian children become "must have" fashion accessories for upper middle-class Americans?
Along with Calloway golf clubs and season tickets to football games, paying $30,000 to $40,000 to adopt an exotic baby is suddenly viewed as the most chic purchase this side of a pair of Manolo Blahnik pumps.
Never mind that thousands of babies of other races -- most of them black -- go without foster homes and adoptions here and elsewhere in this country every year. It doesn't cost tens of thousands of dollars to adopt a black, Latino or mixed-race child.
But for some reason, even Hollywood is marketing Asian babies as somehow superior and more desirable.
That's a shame. Because if people really wanted to adopt children because of a desire to become parents, they'd just adopt babies, not fashion statements.
MY RESPONSE:
Dear Mike,
Where the Heck do I start? Your column oozed of ignorance AND cynicism! Your
column, in my opinion, spoke volumes.... What I got out of it is that *your*
immediate take on international adoption, is frustration and resentment:
perhaps because it' seems easier (it's not); perhaps because as all the
incorrect myths out there have it, you can easily "buy a baby"...(BARF!!)...BUT
mostly, my take on your frustration was that folks consider and *pursue*
international adoption vs. domestic adoption, and that seems to be bone of
contention with you.
I'm curious... before writing this column did you do any research or was this
just a knee-jerk response to 2 movies you watched? Because believe me, the media
(including you) always does an incredible job of "opening mouth and inserting
foot".. Children are NOT fashion accessories! Where do you get off even thinking
that analogy is ok? I suspect you're not a parent and especially not an adoptive
parent.
Yes the media and their various PR reps almost always screw up where
international AND domestic adoption is concerned. Inappropriate language re:
adoption, is tried and true (ask ANY adoptive parent).. the "real child" vs.
the "adopted
child" (they're ALL our real children) is constant and makes most of us adoptive
parents want to hurl on the writer and editors' shoes.
It often appears on the big screen, to the world, that one merely has to put
in an application (and on the big screen, any bozo with a SS# pretty much can do
this) and a few short months later that person has a beautiful baby.
WRONG!! Anything but the truth....... However lies, ignorance, and/or even
denial, usually sells! Far more than the truth! Cause the truth.. yeah, its
sometimes not what we want to believe! AND it often hurts....
Do you realize that to adopt from China right now, it's like a 3-5
year wait? You have to have an income of so many dollars? You have to meet
health standards and have to be between certain ages. You can't be on certain
medications. The media is the media.. glamorizing something sells! You, of all
folks should know that . I'm disappointed you did further disservice by
perpetuating the wrongful information out there with the horrible column you
wrote..
WHAT you should have written is something that provided a well-thought, well
researched argument re: domestic adoption vs. international adoption in an
OBJECTIVE way! Adoption, regardless of whether it's international or domestic,
is about the child. It's about finding the best home for that child! Please
memorize that!
Adoptive parents, and children who are available for adoption
come from everywhere. It's important the match is right. Our Domestic system in
my opinion is unfortunately filled with issues, mostly challenges. I do believe
it's getting better
BUT not fast enough. What my dh and I knew when we adopted was that we would not
survive having
a child placed with us whom we thought would be ours to adopt, only to have them
taken away. It happens and happens often.... a lot... While I'm thrilled that
families are being kept together and I truly believe that children should be
with their birth families if at all possible.....much of what i see is "a
little, a lot too late"..... We need to revamp our system!
Again, I think the system has improved but not fast enough! "Our" (the US)
system was not something we could bank our hearts on and there are many more
like us out there. Until you've been there, please dont judge cause you
obviously just dont get it.. Just like all the journalists who put pen to paper
(fingers to keyboard) and pen away with puns and cutesy analogies.... all of
which does nothing but demoralize an incredible thing: bringing families
together!
So see there.. yet another column you could write!. DONT be putting down
international adoption.. Children everywhere need families.. Yes, many families
go the international route because the parental rights have been severed. NOT
because Asian children, Ethiopian, or Guatemalan children are the latest fashion
accessories and of course I've left out many other international programs. What
I think you're mostly unhappy about is the inadequacies of our own country and
our various programs which find families for children.
Please do your research in the future. It's not only gut-wrenching to see that
some journalists (which many ignorant folks just like the journalist, BELIEVE -
again... BARF!!) can compare a child to a fashion accessory, but the very fact
that you obviously have NO knowledge re: international adoption, bothers me to
no end. I'm not quite sure how your editor could let this go thru.. pretty
pathetic and yes I've got some background in marketing, PR, writing etc.
And yes, to share about myself, I'm the proud parent of 3 beautiful NON fashion
accessories... They are incredible children and we are a family. You dont need
to know where they were born because that's not relevant. What IS relevant is
that our family came together thru adoption.. end of discussion! I hope you might consider doing another column elaborating
on some of your poor verbage/information and (what a concept) after maybe a tad
of research (dont journalists do this anymore??.... barf again) actually
apologizing......Perhaps noone reads your column but believe me, it's made the
rounds on the adoptive family community boards... I wish you the best with your
future career.. I'd highly suggest that retraction/ along with MUCH research...
and the "slap me in the face 'how could I have been so idiotic, retraction'"..
to redeem yourself!.. Good luck!